Wednesday , January 20 2021
Home / US & World / Japan’s detention of ex-Nissan chairman Carlos Ghosn was wrong, human rights panel says

Japan’s detention of ex-Nissan chairman Carlos Ghosn was wrong, human rights panel says

World

A panel of human rights experts working with the United Nations said Monday that former Renault-Nissan boss Carlos Ghosn was wrongly detained in Japan and has urged "compensation" for him from the Japanese government.

Former Renault-Nissan boss Carlos Ghosn speaks during a news conference in Jounieh, Lebanon, in September. Ghosn was awaiting trial in Japan on charges of underreporting future income and breach of trust when he jumped bail and escaped to Lebanon late last year.(Mohamed Azakir/Reuters)

A panel of human rights experts working with the United Nations said Monday that former Renault-Nissan boss Carlos Ghosn was wrongly detained in Japan and has urged "compensation" for him from the Japanese government.

The Japanese government denounced the report as a "totally unacceptable" viewpoint that will change nothing in the country's legal process.

In its opinion published Monday, the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention found that Ghosn's arrest in Japan in late 2018 and early 2019 was "arbitrary" and called on Japan's government to "take the necessary steps to remedy the situation of Mr. Ghosn without delay." A determination of whether detention is arbitrary is based on various criteria, including international norms of justice.

While Ghosn is no longer in Japan, having fled in a dramatic operation last year that drew headlines worldwide, the opinion could weigh on minds in courtrooms in the country and beyond. It could affect, for example, the possible extradition of two Americans, Michael Taylor and his son, Peter, whom Japanese prosecutors say helped the executive sneak out of Japan.

Ghosn, a 66-year-old with French, Lebanese and Brazilian citizenship, led Japanese automaker Nissan for two decades, rescuing it from near-bankruptcy.

He was arrested in November 2018 on charges of breach of trust, in misusing company assets for personal gain, and violating securities laws in not fully disclosing his compensation. He denies wrongdoing.

Last December, Ghosn fled Japan to Lebanon while out on bail awaiting trial, meaning his case will not go on in Japan. Interpol has issued a wanted notice but his extradition from Lebanon is unlikely.

Opinion not binding

The five-member working group, which is made up of independent experts, called on Japan to ensure a "full and independent investigation" of Ghosn's detention, and asked the government "to take appropriate measures against those responsible for the violation of his rights."

The working group said that "the appropriate remedy would be to accord Mr. Ghosn an enforceable right to compensation and other reparations."

The opinions of the working group are not binding on countries but aim to hold them up to their own human rights commitments. One of its past rulings involved the case of Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, who was likewise deemed to have had his human rights violated.

The panel of human rights experts working with the United Nations has previously issued a ruling in the case of Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, likewise concluding that his human rights were violated.(Daniel Leal-Olivas/AFP/Getty Images)

The panel, which is independent from the United Nations, noted a string of allegations from Ghosn and his representatives, such as that he was subjected to solitary confinement and long interrogations during day or night, and denied access to court pleadings. His team claimed that interrogations of Ghosn were aimed to extract a confession.

Japan's system has been repeatedly criticized by human rights advocates. The panel cited previous concerns about Japan's so-called "daiyo kangoku" system of detention and interrogation that relies heavily on confessions and could expose detainees to torture, ill-treatment and coercion.

Japan's Foreign Ministry said in a statement that the government had applied "appropriate procedures" in the case, and it could not provide full information to the working group before a trial had begun. For that reason, the ministry said it would be inappropriate for the working group to make a decision on the Ghosn case "based on limited information and biased allegations" from him and his team.

"The opinion is totally unacceptable, and is not legally binding," the ministry statement said. It also warned that the opinion could set a dangerous precedent, and "encourage those who would stand criminal trial to entertain the idea that flight can be justified and prevent the realization of justice and the proper functioning of the criminal justice system in each country."

"Japan can by no means accept the opinion of the Working Group regarding the case of the defendant Carlos Ghosn," it added.

Ghosn alleges conspiracy

Ghosn lawyer Jessica Finelle welcomed the "brave" decision by the panel and said its members had been "hard on the Japanese legal system" and the way that Japanese authorities treated Mr. Ghosn, "specifically, violating numerous times his presumption of innocence, presenting him as guilty, orchestrating two of his arrests with the media …"

She said Ghosn was "very happy" and "relieved" about the opinion.

He "somehow is getting back his dignity because he's been humiliated during this time that he was held in Japan," she said.

Ghosn has accused Nissan and Japanese officials of conspiring to bring him down to block a fuller integration of Nissan with its French alliance partner Renault SA of France.

Ghosn's lawyers filed a petition with the working group in March last year, appealing to its role to look into cases in which governments are alleged to have wrongly detained individuals under agreed international human rights conventions.

Its members declined to speak to reporters about the opinion, the UN human rights office said.

Credit belongs to : www.cbc.ca

index.php

Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny detained upon arrival back in Russia

World Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny was detained at a Moscow airport after returning from …