Home / Editorial / Before reclamation, think about where the water goes
  • Advertise Here

Before reclamation, think about where the water goes

Former Sen. Cynthia Villar has raised a fundamental issue that the government and proponents of reclamation projects cannot just ignore. What happens to the entire flood-management system when multiple interventions are imposed on the same interconnected coastline?

The question is particularly urgent following the Department of Environment and Natural Resources’ cumulative impact assessment of 22 reclamation projects in Manila Bay and its recommendations. The government should ensure that these recommendations are not merely placed on official record but translated into concrete policy and action.

The environmental review of each project may satisfy specific regulatory requirements. But compliance on a project-by-project basis does not necessarily reveal the cumulative consequences of altering a coastline, narrowing natural pathways, changing water circulation, and placing additional pressure on already vulnerable communities.

Water seeks its own level. Therefore, floodwater does not recognize project boundaries. Neither do rivers, tides, and storm surges.

This reality should be at the center of the government’s policy on Manila Bay reclamation.

The Philippines, particularly Metro Manila and other highly urbanized areas, has already lost substantial natural catchment areas capable of receiving, storing and slowing floodwater. Wetlands, open spaces, waterways and other natural buffers have steadily given way to urban development. As rainfall becomes more intense and extreme weather events become more frequent amid climate change, the margin for error becomes increasingly narrow.

The Las Piñas-Parañaque Wetland Park, a protected area under the Expanded National Integrated Protected Areas System Act of 2018 and a wetland of international importance under the Ramsar Convention, illustrates why the issue extends beyond land creation and economic development. Wetlands and mangroves perform ecological functions while also contributing to natural water regulation and coastal protection.

This does not mean that development must stop. It means development must be subjected to a higher standard of responsibility.

Reclamation proponents understandably point to investments, jobs, infrastructure and new economic opportunities. These benefits are legitimate considerations. But so are the potential costs imposed on communities, ecosystems, fisheries and flood-control systems.
What value will new real estate create if the surrounding communities are left more vulnerable to disaster?

For project proponents, environmental compliance should therefore be regarded not merely as a legal obligation but as a moral responsibility to the communities they intend to serve. Economic gains cannot be measured without accounting for environmental risks and the potential public cost of disasters.

The government, for its part, must demonstrate the political will to act on scientific findings—even when doing so causes inconvenience, delays projects or disappoints powerful interests. Public officials have a responsibility to protect the broader public interest, particularly when the consequences of an irreversible decision may be borne by millions.

The private sector can contribute by adopting climate-resilient designs, protecting natural buffers, managing stormwater and construction waste properly, and supporting infrastructure that strengthens rather than undermines the surrounding flood-management system.

Citizens also have responsibilities. Keeping waterways free of garbage, complying with waste-management policies, protecting wetlands, and demanding transparency and science-based decision-making.

The principle should be straightforward. Before creating more land, the government must determine whether it is also reducing the country’s capacity to accommodate water.

At a time of climate change, the primordial consideration must be the safety and welfare of the greater majority.

Manila Bay should not become another lesson learned only after catastrophe.

The government must act now before the next flood reminds us, at an enormous human cost, that water always finds its own course and seeks its own level.

*****
Credit belongs to: www.mb.com.ph

Check Also

Threats evolve; impunity endures

Apart from remembering the dearly departed on All Souls’ Day, the nation also joined the …